
Former TK vice-chair Biernat: the break-in-duties mechanism is admissible, but doubts remain
TV Sourcetvn24.plWarsaw

On Friday, the longest-serving judge of the Tribunal, Korwin-Piotrowska, ordered a break in the duties of TK chair Bogdan Święczkowski and his deputy Bartłomiej Sochański, citing laws on the Tribunal and on common courts. According to TVN24, lawyers' opinions on this decision are not unanimous. On Saturday, in an interview with TVN24, former TK vice-chair Stanisław Biernat said: “A responsible lawyer cannot say that he has no doubts.”
Biernat believes that “the mechanism itself was admissible”, but he doubts whether the break could be applied to the chair and deputy chair: in his words, the law on common courts refers to such a break in relation to judges. “It cannot be that the law is helpless when very serious charges have been raised about how the chair and deputy chair exercise their office,” he said.
Biernat called the violation of the constitution by the president and the TK chair “unprecedented”; in his view, the chair refused to admit correctly elected judges to service. He fears that the procedural decision of Judge Korwin-Piotrowska will not be recognised by the president, who has the power to appoint the TK chair. As TVN24 recalls, under Article 194 of the Constitution the president appoints the TK chair.
Loading…