
A cell with an executioner: Moczarski, Stroop and the stories of Warsaw’s prisons
МУ SourceМузей независимости · ŻIH · IPNWarsaw

On 2 March 1949, Polish resistance member Kazimierz Moczarski found himself sharing a cell with the man who directed the destruction of the Warsaw ghetto. This was not during German occupation but after the war, in the prison on Rakowiecka Street. That proximity gave rise to “Conversations with an Executioner”, a book about how a person becomes an agent of mass murder.
Warsaw’s prisons cannot be reduced to lists of famous inmates. The Citadel, Pawiak and Mokotów belong to different authorities and eras. Imprisonment might mean punishment for underground resistance, political persecution or the trial of a genuine war criminal.
The Citadel: future opponents on the same side of the prison door
After suppressing the November Uprising, Nicholas I ordered a fortress above the Vistula. Built in 1832–1836, its garrison and artillery were to keep the defiant city under control. The X Pavilion housed a remand prison for political inmates.
Józef Piłsudski and Roman Dmowski passed through it: future rivals offering Poland different paths. Often seen today as opposites, both first confronted the Russian Empire’s repressive system, as the Citadel’s history reminds us. Socialist Ludwik Waryński, poet Gustaw Ehrenberg and Jarosław Dąbrowski, later a participant in the Paris Commune, were also held here.
The most tragic story concerns January Uprising leader Romuald Traugutt. His imprisonment ended in execution: on 5 August 1864 he and four National Government members were hanged beside the Citadel. The X Pavilion should not be seen simply as a “museum of great Poles”: the remand cell was a stage towards release, exile, penal servitude or death.
Pawiak: an Olympic medal offered no protection from occupation terror
Pawiak existed before the Second World War but acquired an especially terrible role under German occupation. Its inmates included Janusz Kusociński, the 1932 Los Angeles Olympic champion over 10 000 metres. A familiar sporting name became part of the history of mass repression.
Other prisoners included former Sejm marshal Maciej Rataj, socialist politician Mieczysław Niedziałkowski and writer Witold Hulewicz, editor of the underground “Polska Żyje”. The Germans shot all four in Palmiry. This geographical distinction matters: imprisonment and murder did not always occur in the same place. Pawiak’s history extends beyond its walls to forest execution sites and families trying to discover where their loved ones were taken.
Rakowiecka: the city’s liberation did not end political imprisonment
After the war, Mokotów Prison became a centre of repression by communist security organs. Members of the Polish underground were held here. In 1948 Witold Pilecki was executed: a resistance member who voluntarily entered Auschwitz to conduct underground work. Later, in 1965, Jacek Kuroń and Karol Modzelewski were imprisoned on Rakowiecka over their “Open Letter to the Party”, criticising the PZPR system.
Decades separate these stories, but the common address shows prison space passing from one system of political control to another. Yet the circumstances of arrests, trials and the responsibility of particular authorities must not be conflated.
Moczarski and Stroop: not reconciliation, but an attempt to understand the machinery of crime
Before the war Moczarski was a journalist and lawyer; during occupation he served in the Home Army and the Warsaw Uprising. He was arrested in August 1945. Later this opponent of the occupiers was falsely accused of collaborating with the Germans.
His cellmate Jürgen Stroop was the SS general who directed the suppression of the Warsaw ghetto uprising in 1943. The third inmate was German policeman Gustav Schielke. A former resistance member and men of the Nazi apparatus thus shared a small room.
According to the Jewish Historical Institute’s account, conditions were especially humiliating for Moczarski: Stroop received letters, parcels and extra food, while the Pole was taken for interrogation and tortured. A shared cell did not make their situations equal.
Moczarski nevertheless questioned Stroop about his childhood, career and beliefs. He wanted to understand not just a particular order but the path to it: how reverence for superiors, career ambition, racial ideology and everyday choices combine into a readiness to kill. This makes the book significant beyond one prison’s history: the criminal emerges through his own explanations, not only a verdict.
One memorable episode concerns a bed. In Moczarski’s recollection, Stroop offered him the bed as a representative of the victorious nation. Moczarski refused to accept that hierarchy. Even in a cell, Stroop understood human relations as domination and submission; for the author, this was another observation of his worldview.
“Conversations with an Executioner” is not a transcript written during the conversations. Moczarski composed it after his release in 1956. Readers must distinguish documented imprisonment, later authorial recollection and interpretation of his interlocutor’s behaviour. Reference publications even disagree on the shared cell’s duration: both 225 and 255 days appear. We therefore do not present the disputed number as an exact fact.
Three addresses, three different conversations about the city
The Citadel reveals Warsaw under imperial control. Pawiak tells of German occupation terror. Rakowiecka concerns postwar persecution of political opponents, but also the detention of Nazi criminals. These histories intersect without becoming the same story.
The distinction is clearest in Moczarski and Stroop’s cell. Shared walls do not equalise biographies. One was an unjustly persecuted resistance member; the other was responsible for mass crimes. Preserving that difference makes their conversations historical testimony rather than a sensational prison legend.
Sources and photographs
Museum of Independence — history of the X Pavilion: https://muzn.pl/pl/about/cytadelas-history/
IPN — Pawiak inmates and executions in Palmiry: https://ipn.gov.pl/pl/aktualnosci/202780,Obchody-upamietniajace-84-rocznice-egzekucji-wiezniow-Pawiaka-w-Palmirach-21-cze.html
Jewish Historical Institute — Przemysław Batorski’s article on Moczarski and Stroop: https://www.jhi.pl/artykuly/2-marca-1949-kazimierz-moczarski-trafia-do-celi-z-jurgenem-stroopem-katem-getta-warszawskiego,572
IPN, “Tajemnice Rakowieckiej”: https://polska1918-89.pl/pdf/tajemnice-rakowieckiej,6243.pdf
ZPE educational platform — the book and the period of its creation: https://zpe.gov.pl/a/przeczytaj/De7bky3Wt
Illustration photographs: present-day Mokotów Prison on Rakowiecka (Wistula, CC BY-SA 3.0); Pawiak from Dzielna Street, 1906 (public domain); a German notice signed by Stroop banning entry to the former ghetto, 1943 (public domain, Wikimedia Commons). These are separate images of different places and eras, not a photograph of the shared cell.
Loading…